Skip to main content


To Feinstein's/
54 Below

Everyone has dreams that we fear will pass us by. For actors those come in the shape and form of roles—whether they’re grown up and become too old for that child star turn, to the soprano never being considered for the baritone lead, everyone has a song in their heart that they’ll likely never get to see come to fruition with a crowd and in lights.

Until tonight.

I Wish: The Roles That Could Have Been — is just that chance for all to embody those “roles come true,” and for an audience to bear witness to actors living out those dreams. Join us for a night of surprise, as you see and hear your favorite performers in ways you’d never imagine them.

Joe Carroll (Frozen, Bandstand)
Erin Davie (Grey Gardens, Side Show, Diana)
Jennifer DiNoia (Wicked)
Ali Ewoldt (The Phantom of the Opera, The King and I)
Alex Finke (Come From Away, Sweeney Todd)
Andrew Kober
 (School Of Rock, Alice By Heart)
Mauricio Martínez (On Your Feet!)
Zachary Noah Piser (Dear Evan Hansen, Wicked)
Rachel Potter (The Addams Family, Evita)
Caesar Samayoa (Come From Away)
Heath Saunders (The Great Comet, Alice By Heart)
Michael James Scott (Aladdin, Something Rotten!)
Elena Shaddow (The Bridges of Madison County, The King and I)

and more to be announced!

Hosted by Jelani Remy (Ain’t Too Proud, Smokey Joe’s Cafe, Lion King)
Conceived by Alexandra Silber
Musical Direction by Ben Caplan
Produced by Jen Sandler 

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.


  • $30 – $40
  • Premiums: $65
  • Additional $6 If Purchased At Venue
  • $25 Food & Beverage Minimum
Buy Tickets View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales View Seat Map