To Feinstein's/
54 Below

After 2 sold out shows last year, Buffy, Spike, Xander, Anya, Willow, Tara, Dawn, Giles, and everyone’s favorite dancing demon are back to do it…well, once more with feeling! Starring a cast of Broadway favorites (who are also “Buffy” fanatics), the evening will feature music from the cult-hit “Buffy The Vampire Slayer” musical episode, “Once More, With Feeling,” written by Joss Whedon.

After Buffy comes back from the dead (again), the Scooby Gang and the residents of Sunnydale find themselves bursting into song (and flame) when a demon attempts to make Dawn his bride. Will Buffy be able to save the day while singing and dancing?? This sure to be a high stakes evening you don’t want to miss!

Emily Borromeo (Broadway Bounty Hunter, School of Rock)
Corey Hummerston (Hello, Dolly!, The Book of Mormon)
Autumn Hurlbert (Something Rotten!, Legally Blonde)
Denis Lambert (Doctor Zhivago, Encores! A Chorus Line)
Sydney Patrick (Kinky Boots)
Jenny Pinzari (Pop Filter, Fauxchella Music Festival)
Allison Posner (Volleygirls, The Last Song of Eddie Scourge)
Nathan Richardson (Freaky Friday)
Dennis Stowe (Aladdin, Annie)
Kalyn West (The Prom)

and more to be announced soon!

Directed by Tyler Spicer
Music Directed by Drew Wutke
Choreographed by MiMi Scardulla
Produced by Shoshana Feinstein 

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.


  • $30 – $45
  • Premiums: $50 – $75
  • Additional $6 If Purchased At Venue
  • For 9:30pm: $25 Food & Beverage Minimum
  • For 11:30pm: 2 Drink or $20 Food & Beverage Minimum
Buy Tickets View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales


  • Seasonal Crudites

    Lemon Hummus

  • Buffalo Mozzarella Bruschetta

    Olive Tapanade

  • Guacamole with Plantain Chips
  • Bacon Mac and Cheese
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    Marinara Sauce

  • Nachos

    Cheddar, Black Beans, Pickled Jalapenos, Sour Cream, Sliced Avocado

  • Spicy Chicken Wings

    Blue Cheese Dipping Sauce

  • Watermelon Gazpacho

    Feta, Avocado

  • Mushroom Arancini

    Cheese Fondue, Parsley Oil

  • Mixed Green Salad

    Dried Cherries, Goat Cheese, Honey Dijon Dressing

  • Charcuterie and Cheese

    Toasted Baguette

  • Fried Calamari

    Marinara Sauce

  • Buttermilk Battered Fried Chicken Tenders

    Creamy Herb Dressing

  • Ceasar Salad

    Baby Red Romaine Lettuce, Baby Greens, Shaved Parmesan, Parmesan Crisps, Soft Boiled Egg, Anchovy, Housemade Ceasar Dressing

  • Lemon Ricotta Ravioli

    Butter Poached Lobster, Spicy Breadcrumbs

  • Peekytoe Crab Fritters

    Avocado, Roasted Tomato Vinaigrette

  • Vegan Red Quinoa Pilaf

    Roasted Sweet Potatoes, Sauteed Chard, Hen of the Woods Mushrooms

  • Pan -Seared Arctic Char

    Black Pepper and Lemon Spaetzle, Baby Artichoke, Olive Oil, Thyme Roasted Tomatoes

  • 54 Below Bacon Cheeseburger

    Short Ribs and Brisket, Chipotle Spread, Shoestring Fries

  • Espresso-Marinated Hanger Steak

    Pommes Frites

  • Mashed Potatoes
  • Shoestring French Fries
  • Buttermilk Battered Onion Rings
  • Seasonal Vegetables
  • Tiramisu Cheesecake

    Rum Cheesecake, Lady Fingers, Espresso Cream, Espresso Gelato

  • Rich Chocolate Cake

    Godiva Liqueur Chocolate Mousse, Salted Caramel, Vanilla Gelato

  • Homemade Cookie Plate
  • Doughnuts

    Caramel Sauce, Hot Fudge

  • Ice Cream Sandwiches

    Chocolate Chip Cookies, Vanilla Gelato

  • Waffle Cup

    Chocolate Gelato, Whip Cream, Hot Fudge, Chocolate Crunch

  • 54 Below Manhattan

    Rough Rider Rye, Dolin Rouge Vermouth, Grand Marnier, Angostura Bitters

  • Big Apple

    Tito's Vodka, Apple Schnapps, Lime, Domaine de Canton, Ginger Ale

  • Password

    Brokers Gin, Creme de Violetta, Cassis, Lime, Club Soda

  • Last Call

    Four Roses Bourbon, Malibu Rum, Raw Simple, Lemon, Lime

  • Cain't Say No

    Milagro Silver Tequila, Chambord, Angustora Bitters, Lemon, Sprite

  • Anastasia

    Pomegranate Grenadine, Lemon, Soda

  • Nala

    Lime Juice, Honey, Soda

  • Zardetto Prosecco

    Conegliano,Italy NV

  • Chandon Sparkling Rose

    Napa, CA

    Glass - $14.00
    Bottle - $55.00
  • Saracco Moscato d'Asti

    Piedmont, Italy 2017

  • Zenato

    Pinot Grigio delle Venezia, Italy

  • Echo Bay

    Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough, New Zealand 2017

    Glass - $15.00
    Bottle - $60.00
  • La Crema

    Chardonnay, Monterey, CA 2017

  • Sangiovese

    Vitiano, Falseco, IT 2017

  • Famille Perrin

    Cotes du Rhone, France 2015

  • Benziger

    Cabernet Sauvignon Sonoma, CA 2015

  • Chateau Auguste -- Red

    Bordeaux, France 2015

  • Domaine de la Chaise-- Rose

    Touraine, France 2018

  • Mionetto Prosecco

    Valdobbiadene, Italy NV

  • Gruner Veltliner

    Wachau, Austria 2018

  • Chateau St. Michelle Reisling

    Columbia Valley, Washington 2016

  • Seven Deadly Zins

    Lodi, California 2016

  • Allegash White

    Portland, ME

  • Keegan Mother's Milk Stout

    Kingston, NY

  • Original Sin--Hard Apple Cider

    Hudson Valley, NY

  • Buckler Non- Alcoholic


  • Draft Beer

    Ask your server about our seasonal draft choices

    Draft - $9.00
    add a shot of whiskey, rye, or tequila - $6.00
  • Tequila Flight

    Milagro Silver, Reposada, Anejo, Baha Mezcal

  • Whiskey/Rye Flight

    Four Roses, Rough Ryder Rye, Bulliet Bourbon and Rye

  • View Seat Map