To Feinstein's/
54 Below

Feinstein’s/54 Below is excited to welcome back Tyler Conroy for the fifth installment of his Broadway Bae series – a cabaret featuring Broadway’s hottest & rising stars performing music from the shows they’ve been in and pop songs you love to sing in the shower. After a sold-out Christmas-themed show, the Broadway Baes will be going Halloween with selections from Wicked, Hocus Pocus, and even “Schitt’s Creek.” If you love scream-singing to songs from middle school dances & living your best life, then you will love this journey for you at Tyler Conroy’s Broadway Baes Halloween. He will be joined by his Broadway Baes Band which features his dad, who is the reason why music is the best part of his life. P.S. Dressing in costume is highly encouraged, if you don’t then that’s “ew, David!” 

Tyler Conroy is a 27-year-old Taylor Swift enthusiast currently burning the Yankee Candle at both ends in New York City. He has performed in over twenty Feinstein’s/54 Below shows, but he is most known on the internet for his viral videos in which he sings his orders at Taco Bell drive-thrus. You can stalk him @tyvid5 to see other weird videos and also check out his Taylor Swift biography, “This Is Our Song,” published by Simon & Schuster which features a photo of him with Taylor Swift from the time she invited him over for pizza.

The Baes:

Phoenix Best (Dear Evan Hansen)
Melanie Brook (Summertime Dropouts)
Adrian Grace Bumpas (Broadway Baes)
Joey Contreras (Composer)
Ian Fairlee (Three Points of Contact)
Jacob Haren (Book of Mormon)
Peter LaPrade (This Ain’t No Disco)
Jiana Odland (Broadway Baes)
Luca Padovan (Newsies, School of Rock)
Jelani Remy (Ain’t Too Proud, Lion King)
Chris Rice (Pretty Woman, Book of Mormon)
Colton Ryan (Girl From North Country)
Anthony Sagaria (Wicked)
Diamond Essence White (Dear Evan Hansen)
Marco Zefi (54 Sings Taylor Swift

The Bae Band:

T.J. Conroy (Guitar, Vocals)
Daniel Mertzlufft (Music Director)
Joshua Roberts (Drums)
Elmo Zapp (Bass)

Please note that all artists and acts are subject to change at any time.

Past Performances

  • Sat, Oct 5: 11:30 pm
View Seating Chart Find Out about Group Sales


  • Plantain Chips

    with Guacamole

  • Bacon Mac & Cheese
  • Charcuterie & Cheese

    with Grilled Baguette

  • Buttermilk Marinated Fried Chicken Tenders

    Creamy Herb Dressing

  • Spring Crudite

    Lemon Hummus

  • Farmstead Cheese Plate
  • Watermelon Gazpacho

    Feta Cheese, Avocado

  • Peekytoe Crab Fritters

    Avocado, Roasted Tomato Vinaigrette

  • Buffalo Mozzarella Bruschetta

    Olive Tapenade, Roasted Red Pepper

  • Fried Calamari

    Marinara Sauce

  • Mushroom Arancini

    Parmesan Cheese Fondue

  • Mixed Green

    Honey Dijon Dressing

  • Warm Farro

    Roasted Mushrooms, Shaved Celery, Baby Kale, Black Mustard Seed Vinaigrette

  • 54/Bacon Cheeseburger

    Short Rib & Brisket Beef Burger, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Spring Brook Reading Cheese, Chipotle Spread, Shoestring Fries

  • Duck Confit Salad

    Frisee, Caramelized Grapefruit, Citrus Vinaigrette

  • Organic Egg Omelette

    Goat Cheese, Spinach, Baby Mixed Green Salad, Shoestring French Fries

  • Shoestring French Fries
  • Broccolini
  • Shishito Peppers
  • Buttermilk-Battered Onion Rings
  • Buttermilk Panna Cotta

    Blueberry Compote, Fresh Berries, Strawberry Gelato

  • Homemade Cookie Plate
  • Dark Chocolate Marshmallow Cake

    Dark Chocolate Cake, Marshmallow Buttercream, S'mores Gelato

  • Affogato di Caffe

    Vanilla Gelato, Single Espresso Shot, Cookie Crisp

  • Gelato & Sorbet

    Chef's Seasonal Selection

  • View Seat Map